Inventory: Eye Primer, Mascara, and Brow Products

Posted on May 23, 2017 under Inventory

I’ve collapsed these categories because they’re small and too boring to warrant their own posts. I do have a fair amount of eyeliner, so I’ve decided do that separately, in a post which will be coming at you one day in the future. (Don’t you love that vagueness? I never know which inventory post I’ll be in the mood for on any given day, so I can’t give you an accurate timeline. But I think I have about 5 posts left in this series.)

Eye Primer

My first tube of the NARS eye primer was the business, but the second tube let me down. I don’t know if they reformulated or if my eyelids just started rejecting it, but either way I was not about to drop another $30 on something that didn’t work for me anymore. I’d heard good things about the Milani Eyeshadow Primer, and for under ten bucks that was a risk I could take. This is actually a great primer; it keeps my eyeshadow perfectly intact for 12+ hours. I like the hygienic squeeze tube packaging, although occasionally I squeeze too hard and squirt out an excessive amount of product. User error notwithstanding, I think this product is a gem and a bargain! I just wish Milani were more widely-available in Canada – the drugstore chain that sells the brand is relatively rare.

Mascara

I bought the L’Oreal Voluminous Eye Primer to layer with my coloured mascaras, hoping that the white base would help the colour pop more. It does work to this end, but I find that I have to put on quite a lot of it to get my lashes white, which creates some clumpiness. I just resign myself to the fact that bright blue mascara is a #look, clumpy lashes included.

Though I’m generally a fan of Canadian drugstore brand Marcelle, I wasn’t expecting much from their Ultimate Fringe Effect Mascara when my boss included it in my annual Christmas goodie bag. However, when I cracked it open I ended up being quite impressed. It’s both volumizing and lengthening, and it doesn’t clump easily. I’ve liked it slightly more as it’s aged; I’ve found it gives more length than volume compared to when I first opened it. I prefer a slightly more defined, lengthened look, but it’s a great all-in-one option for those who are into that. Bonus: Marcelle mascaras seem to work really well for my customers with sensitive eyes.

Overall, I really like the YSL Effet Faux Cils Mascara in Bleu Majorelle. It’s a beautiful bright blue, it gives me amazing length, and it’s easy to remove even though it’s waterproof. I don’t like that it has a floral scent and I wouldn’t buy the black because it’s $37, which is absurd. However, I might repurchase this with Optimum points because it is really good and sometimes you just have to spend your points on silly, whimsical things.

Lancôme Grandiôse Extrême Mascara in Le Bleu Nuit* was a press sample which I gleefully received at the end of 2016. Although I like the Hypnôse mascara and several of its spinoffs, I do not get on with the Grandiôse mascara line. I like this one slightly better than the original Grandiôse and I do like the subtle interest navy blue mascara brings to a makeup look, but this mascara totally kills a curl and it’s just not lengthening enough for me.

I forgot to photograph it, but I do have a tube of Clarins Truly Waterproof Mascara on backup, which I’ll open once my Marcelle one dies. (Honestly, the Marcelle one could go now, but I have a wedding in mid-July that I’ll need waterproof mascara for, so I’m trying to wait to open my Clarins…)

Brow Products

Nothing has really changed in my brow routine in several years now. Each day I fill them in with Maybelline Colour Tattoo in Tough As Taupe on an angled brush (I’m on my second pot now!), then set with a clear brow gel. Right now I’m on my second tube of L’Oreal Brow Stylist Plumper in Transparent. It really pisses me off that this stuff costs $15.99, and I try to buy it when it’s on sale (I got it for $5 once), but it is really good. It holds my brow hairs in place but doesn’t look or feel wet or crunchy. I think I’m finally ready to upgrade from my $3 Essence brow gel, but I’ll have to only buy this stuff on sale because $16 for a drugstore brow gel is MADNESS. On quick/lazy days, I have a tube of Benefit Gimme Brow in the old packaging kicking around. I like this product a lot, but do keep in mind that it’s best-suited to someone who already has pretty full, well-shaped brows. This tube never seems to die, though that could be since I use it rarely – maybe three or four times a month.

And that concludes this boring amalgamation of categories! Next up you’ll see either foundation/concealer/powder or highlighter/bronzer. We shall see where my whims carry me…

There are 4 responses to “Inventory: Eye Primer, Mascara, and Brow Products”

  • I do my inventories whenever it pleases me to do so, too. And randomly. I only have one fun category left and then a bunch of boring ones so I’ve dragging it out.

    Have you tried the L’Oreal voluminous mascara in Cobalt Blue? I like it to get my bright blue mascara fix. I might try a white primer to get it to show up, too, but so far I’m too lazy to buy one.

    • I have some boring categories left, too. :( I think I’ll save lipstick for last, because it’s the most fun and will take the most time.

      I haven’t tried that mascara! I did try the L’Oreal Miss Manga blue one when they had that a few years ago. It was alright, but the colour was a bit dull. I think my lashes are a bit too dark for coloured mascaras to show up well, which I know sounds like a humblebrag.

    • Sadly a lot of high end brands do it! They just put floral scents in all of their products regardless. I don’t mind it so much in a blush, but in eye or lip products it’s pretty awful.

Leave a Reply

Please feel free to leave a comment; I'd love to hear your thoughts on this post. Please don't leave a link to your blog in the body of your comment. If you leave your URL in the appropriate field in the form I will be able to click your name and check out your blog. Comments that don't adhere to this policy will be edited or deleted.